Home Mission Statement About the Company The Authors Consulting Services Contact Us
Program Overview
Employer State Labor Posting Requirements
Map Information
Customer Service
New Partnership Program

High court mulls age discrimination

Click to view ruling

Supreme Court Makes Proving Discrimination Easier

In June 2003 the Court held that “direct” evidence was not necessary in order to place the burden of proof on an Employer when discrimination is alleged. The meaning for Employers is that Employees who claim discrimination have a better chance of getting heard by a jury than in the past.

The evidence of discrimination is usually circumstantial. In such cases the Employer puts on evidence of the legitimate motive for it’s actions and the Employee must then show that the asserted reason is false. This standard allowed Courts to throw out many cases under the summary judgment procedure-thus no trial ever occurred. In some very rare cases the Employee has evidence, usually in the form of a clear statement from the company’s decision maker, that an unlawful motive is motivating the decision. In these rare instances the burden of proof is shifted to the Company to show it would have made the same decision even if the illegal motive were not in mind-a much harder thing to prove.

In Desert Palace, Inc. v. Costa, the Court held that such “direct” evidence was not required to shift this burden to the Employer. The Court concluded that for the case to go to the jury circumstantial evidence alone was sufficient, if enough such evidence was present that a “reasonable jury” could find discrimination.

The Desert Palace, case involved an interpretation of Title VII of the Civil Rights Act (covering race, sex, national origin and religion). Whether this same standard will be applied to the age discrimination act and the other anti-discrimination statutes remains to be seen.

What it means to Employers is that more cases will result in jury trials. It also may motivate more Employees to require mandatory arbitration agreements to be signed by Employees.







Flagship Federal Program
The Flagship Program for All States, currently utilized by the SBDC as a reference resource to provide sound guidance to their members
click for more info

Small Business Version
For companies with less than 15 employees. Highly recommended by the SBDC (Small Business Development Centers)... (more)
click for more info

State of Texas Specific Programs
Now available for an introductory offer of (more)
click for more info

New Partner Program
We are now pleased to announce our new Partnering Program for with Professional HR and Business Management and Operations Consultants as VARS... (more)
click for more info


Department of Labor



Texas Workforce Commission

Department of Labor Statistics

Supreme Court Ruling

Contact Information

Your Employment Risk Solutions, Inc.
P.O Box 4664
Horeshoe Bay, TX 78657

Telephone Numbers:
Corporate Office:
(830) 596 • 8538
Product Information:
1 • 800 • 438 • 9377

contact Maryah Sautter

© 2006 Your Employment Risk Solutions, Inc. Site Development by and hosting provided by toImagine